Today’s edition is sponsored by Crisp
As your accounts scale from your first customers to a global base, Crisp scales with you. One platform that supports enterprise and worldwide capacity, so you keep the same system instead of a rip-and-replace every few years. Free trial on us →
You know your base salary cold.
But if I asked what your equity is worth, could you tell me?
Most CSMs can’t. I’ve seen people with ten years in the field go blank on this. They don’t know which kind of equity they hold, what it rests on, or whether it’s worth anything at all.
The headline number on your offer is the least reliable one on the page.
The gap between what an offer looks like and what it pays you is almost always hiding in the equity.
Your Comp Has Three Layers, and You Only Read One
A CS offer has three parts: base, variable, and equity.
Base is the number you can trust. It shows up every month and it does what it says.
The other two are where offers diverge from reality.
I wrote about the variable side in the Datadog breakdown, where the split and the metrics behind it decide whether the on-target number is real.
Equity is the layer most people miss, and it is often the one companies lean on hardest to make an offer look big.
Options and RSUs Are Not the Same Thing
The first thing to know is which kind of equity you were actually offered, because the two behave differently.
Options give you the right to buy shares later at a fixed price, called the strike price.
They are worth something only if the company’s share price climbs above that strike, and worth nothing if it does not.
RSUs are shares granted to you outright as they vest, so they hold value as long as the company does.
A big options number and a big RSU number are not comparable, and treating them as the same figure is how people overvalue an offer.
If you cannot tell from your paperwork which one you hold, that is the first question to ask.
Why the Equity Headline Lies
Say the offer includes equity described as worth a large sum. That figure rests on assumptions that may not hold.
It depends on 4 things:
The current price per share, which for a private company is a number set at the last funding round and not a market price.
The total share count, which decides what your grant is actually a slice of.
The vesting schedule, often four years with a one-year cliff, meaning you get nothing if you leave inside the first year.
The distance to a liquidity event, because equity you cannot sell is not money in your pocket, it is a claim that pays out only if and when the company exits.
Change any one of those and the headline number moves a lot.
The figure on the offer letter is the most optimistic reading of all of them at once.
Company Stage Changes the Whole Picture
This is where the offer’s shape depends on where the company sits.
At an early-stage startup, comp leans on equity, and that equity is a lottery ticket.
The base is often lower, the upside is real but unlikely, and you are being paid partly in the hope of an exit.
As a company scales to become a global, late-stage, or public footing, the mix flips.
Base rises, equity becomes RSUs with a knowable value, and the whole package gets more predictable and less of a gamble.
Neither is better in the abstract.
They are different bets, and the offer only makes sense once you know which bet you are being asked to take.
A large equity figure at a seed-stage company and the same figure at a public one are two completely different offers wearing the same number.
What to Ask Before You Sign
Five questions turn the black box into something you can read.
Ask:
Which type of equity it is, options or RSUs.
The strike price and the current price per share.
The total shares outstanding, so you know what fraction you hold.
The vesting schedule and the cliff.
The company’s own view on timeline to a liquidity event, knowing the answer is a hope, not a promise.
You will not always get clean answers, and how a company responds to these questions tells you something too.
A team that treats them as reasonable is one that respects what it is offering you.
If you want a second read before you respond, I'll go through the offer with you and help you avoid leaving money on the table. Book your coaching →
Before You Sign, Remember This
The base is the number you can trust.
Read the variable for whether the on-target figure is real, and read the equity hardest of all, because that is where an offer inflates.
Know which kind you hold, what it rests on, and which bet the company’s stage is asking you to make.
For the fuller picture on what CS roles pay and how to negotiate the whole package, the compensation guide will help you dig into it.
If you’re looking for your next offer, the strongest CS roles are on the TopCSJobs board.
-Hakan, The CS Café
Wednesday edition, a free weekly read on what protects your accounts and your career.